We recently had the chance to showcase two variants of the RoseCraft Traditional Otter Creek Barlow – the Stag and Blue Denim Micarta versions – and the response has been fantastic. These knives represent everything we love about modern traditional pocket knives, and we’re excited to share our thoughts.
The Otter Creek Barlow Specs
The RoseCraft Blades Otter Creek Barlow is a thoughtfully designed traditional slip joint that hits all the right notes:
- Blade: 2.9″ D2 Clip Point with brushed satin finish
- Thickness: 2.7mm for optimal cutting performance
- Features: Half stop and swedging for safety and aesthetics
- Construction: Single blade traditional slip joint
- Bolsters: Brushed steel with distinctive ‘Otter Print’ mark
- Liners: Steel construction throughout
- Dimensions: 3.5″ closed, 6.4″ overall
- Weight: 2.7oz – substantial but not heavy
- Designer: Andy Armstrong
Handle Showdown: Stag vs. Blue Denim Micarta
During our hands-on comparison, we had the opportunity to handle both the Stag (RCT020-STG) and Blue Denim Micarta (RCT020-BDM) variants. While both are beautifully executed, there was a clear preference for the Blue Denim Micarta version.
Why the Blue Denim Micarta won:
- Smoother feel in hand compared to the textured stag
- Consistent grip without the natural variations of horn
- Modern aesthetic that complements the traditional design
- Durability that will age gracefully with use
Don’t get us wrong – stag handles have their devoted following, and RoseCraft’s execution is flawless. But for everyday carry and extended use, the Blue Denim Micarta just felt more refined and practical.
What Makes This Barlow Special
The Otter Creek Barlow succeeds because it respects traditional design while incorporating modern materials and manufacturing precision. The D2 steel choice is particularly smart – it offers excellent edge retention while remaining easy to sharpen. The brushed satin finish is both practical and attractive, hiding scratches while providing a professional appearance.
The half-stop is a standout feature that adds safety without compromising the traditional feel. Combined with the swedging, it shows RoseCraft’s attention to both form and function.
Looking Ahead: Our Special Factory Order
Based on the positive response to these knives, we’re exploring a Special Factory Order (SFO) with RoseCraft Blades. Here’s what we’re considering:
Size Adjustment: We’re thinking slightly smaller than the current 3.5″ closed model – possibly around 3″ closed for better pocket carry while maintaining the classic Barlow proportions.
Blade Configuration: Staying with the clip point design that works so well in the current model, but scaled appropriately for the smaller frame.
Handle Materials Under Consideration:
- Canvas Micarta for a different texture while maintaining the smooth feel we prefer
- Black Linen Micarta for a classic, grippy option that ages beautifully
- Natural Canvas Micarta as a middle ground between synthetic and natural materials
- Smooth Bone for traditionalists who want refinement over texture
We Want Your Input
This is where you come in. We’re committed to creating something the community actually wants to carry and use. What would you like to see in our RoseCraft SFO?
Specific feedback we’re looking for:
- Handle material preferences and why
- Thoughts on the 3″ closed size target
- Any blade finish preferences
- Bolster treatment ideas
- Other details that matter to you
How to Share Your Thoughts: Send us your feedback and suggestions. Whether you’re a traditional knife purist or someone who appreciates modern updates to classic designs, we want to hear from you.
Coming Soon
Keep an eye out for our upcoming RoseCraft giveaway and more details on the SFO as we finalize the specifications. With your input, we’re confident we can create something special that honors the traditional Barlow design while meeting the needs of today’s knife enthusiasts.
The RoseCraft Otter Creek Barlow proves that traditional doesn’t have to mean outdated. Sometimes the best innovations are the subtle ones that improve daily use without losing the soul of the original design.
What would your ideal RoseCraft Barlow SFO look like? Let us know in the comments or reach out directly with your suggestions.
